INTRODUCTION
The Court of Appeal in Petron Malaysia Refining & Marketing Bhd v Magna Enigma Sdn Bhd [2026] MLJU 2697; [2026] 7 CLJ 887 held that a signed Letter of Offer (“LOO”) constituted a valid, binding and enforceable contract even though the parties never signed the contemplated Retail Trading Agreement (“RTA”).
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petron Malaysia Refining & Marketing Bhd (“Petron”) issued the LOO on 7.1.2019 for the construction and operation of a Petron-branded petrol station in Bangi, Selangor.
Magna Enigma Sdn Bhd (“Magna”) executed the LOO on 15.1.2019, accepting Option 2. Option 3 would have added underground tanks and fuel piping to the assets supplied under Option 2.
The LOO provided for a dealer-owned, dealer-operated station. Magna is required to erect the station at its own cost, obtain approvals and enter into a 15-year RTA once the station was built. It also specified Petron’s financial assistance, minimum sales volumes and dealer margins.
When the development charge exceeded expectations and Magna’s RM3.9 million loan proved insufficient, Magna requested a change to Option 3 by WhatsApp on 22.11.2019 and by letter on 10.12.2019. The WhatsApp request also sought a switch to a company-owned, dealer-operated model.
Petron rejected the request on 27.3.2020. Magna continued to take steps to establish the station and pledged exclusivity, but informed Petron by WhatsApp on 26.10.2020 that it would not proceed.
On 4.12.2020, Magna contracted with Shell to operate a station on the same land.
The High Court dismissed Petron’s claim. The High Court treated Magna’s request for Option 3 as a counter-offer and held that no binding contract had been concluded. In the alternative, it held that Magna had not breached the LOO.
FINDINGS OF THE COURT OF APPEAL
Parties Intended the Letter of Offer to Be Binding
The Court of Appeal determined consensus ad idem objectively from the parties’ language and conduct, the surrounding circumstances and the object of the contract.
The revocation clause in Petron’s favour (Clause 11 of the LOO) was a strong indicator of an intention to create legal relations. Magna’s execution of the LOO and the Confidentiality and Non-Disclosure Agreement and its steps towards establishing the station confirmed that intention. The LOO contained no “subject to contract” clause.
The Court read the term “would consider appointing” in the context of Item 2 of the LOO, which obliged Magna to enter into the RTA.
Petron’s consideration of the appointment was conditioned on Magna fulfilling the preliminary conditions.
In this “two-stage contractual process”, the LOO set out the essential commercial terms for establishing the station, while the RTA would govern its operation and the ongoing supply, sale and purchase of petroleum products.
Under the LOO, Petron was to enter into the RTA once land conversion was completed and individual title was issued. Both requirements had been fulfilled by 23.7.2020. The condition was for Petron’s benefit and could be waived by Petron. Non-fulfilment could suspend Petron’s obligation to enter into the RTA while the LOO remained binding.
Option 3 Request Was a Proposed Variation
Pursuant to Section 7 of the Contracts Act 1950, acceptance must be absolute and unqualified. A counter-offer can arise only before acceptance has been communicated. Magna’s initial acceptance on 15.1.2019 extinguished the original offer. Magna’s later request for Option 3 was a proposal to vary an existing contract.
A binding variation required a new agreement supported by fresh consideration. Petron rejected Magna’s proposal. Therefore, the LOO on Option 2 remained in full force.
Withdrawal Amounted to Wrongful Repudiation
Magna’s decision to “withdraw from Petron”, communicated by WhatsApp on 26.10.2020, evinced an intention no longer to be bound.
The withdrawal was a repudiatory breach of the primary obligations to erect the station, enter into the RTA and sell Petron products. Petron could treat the contract as discharged and claim damages.
Evidence Supported Three Years of Lost Profits
The principle underlying Section 74 of the Contracts Act 1950 is to place the injured party in the financial position it would have occupied had the contract been performed.
Petron claimed expectation damages of RM11,572,200.00 over the full 15-year term or, alternatively, RM2,314,440.00 over the three-year average replacement period.
Petron adduced actual monthly sales volumes for 2019–2022 from four comparable stations. Petron’s evidence that a station generally took three years from execution of the LOO to commence operations was unchallenged. Once an LOO was signed and accepted, Petron would reserve the entire trade area for that site and reject other potential investors.
The 15-year claim assumed profitable operations without interruption. The three-year measure directly compensated Petron for the delay and lost opportunity over the period it would take to bring an alternative station into operation. The loss arose naturally from the repudiation and was not “remote and indirect” under Section 74(2).
The Court of Appeal set aside the High Court’s decision and awarded Petron RM2,314,440.00 in damages, together with costs and interest.
CONCLUSION AND KEY TAKEAWAYS
Parties who do not intend to be bound until execution of a formal contract should make clear that their negotiations and exchanges are subject to contract.
In this case, the fact that the station was never completed did not make the claim for loss of profits speculative. The projection rested on reliable, objective data from comparable operations, and the loss flowed naturally from the breach.
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice or legal opinion. It should not be relied upon as a substitute for specific legal advice. No person should act (or refrain from acting) based on this article without obtaining advice on the specific facts and circumstances. Halim Hong & Quek does not accept responsibility or liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this article. Halim Hong & Quek reserves the right to update, amend or withdraw this article at any time. All rights reserved.
Subscribe to DISPUTES DECODED BY HHQ, our bi-monthly legal update, at https://mailchi.mp/hhq/2nofd6rjlt to receive our latest legal updates and articles. You may also visit the HHQ website at https://hhq.com.my/insights/ for further articles and insights from our team.
About the authors
Chew Jin Heng
Principal Associate
Dispute Resolution
Halim Hong & Quek
jhchew@hhq.com.my