The UK Supreme Court ruled in Drelle v Servis-Terminal LLC [2026] UKSC 29 that a creditor holding an unrecognised and unregistrable foreign money judgment no longer needs to obtain recognition from the English court before serving a statutory demand and presenting a bankruptcy petition under Section 267 of the Insolvency Act 1986 (“1986 Act”). The decision is persuasive in Malaysia. Its practical effect here is uneven; little change for individual bankruptcy but a potentially significant opening for winding up companies.
BACKGROUND
Servis-Terminal LLC (“ST”), a Russian company, obtained a judgment from a Russian court ordering its former Director General, Mr Valeriy Drelle (“Mr Drelle”) to pay RUB 2 billion. Mr Drelle had since settled in London. ST served him with a statutory demand in October 2020 and then presented a bankruptcy petition. After a three-day trial, a bankruptcy order was made in March 2023 and upheld by the High Court in 2024. In January 2025 the Court of Appeal reversed that result. It held that a foreign judgment has no legal effect in England until an English court recognises it, so it could not support a bankruptcy petition. The Supreme Court has now unanimously overturned that decision.
THE UK SUPREME COURT’S DECISION
The UK Supreme Court held the following:
- a) The principle upon which foreign judgments for a debt are enforceable in England and Wales is that at common law, whereby a foreign judgment for a debt or definite sum of money gives rise to an obligation to pay the sum – that obligation arises when the final and conclusive judgment is given and does not depend upon recognition.
- b) The term “debt” in the 1986 Act is to be construed as a fresh, separate piece of legislation and a departure from the Bankruptcy Act 1914 (“1914 Act”), whereas the term “judgment debt” in the 1914 Act plainly meant an English judgment or a registered foreign judgment (since an unregistered or unrecognised foreign judgment could not have been the subject of execution in England).
- c) The 1986 Act requires only that a “qualifying debt” (whether a judgment debt or not) is one which the debtor appears to be unable to pay, or to have no reasonable prospect of being able to pay, where the inability to pay may only be established upon the failure of the debtor to respond to a statutory demand, or execution of a judgment debt being returned unsatisfied. There is no requirement that the statutory demand be based upon a judgment debt at all – any debt will do.
- d) In general common law terms, a “debt” is a legal obligation owed by one person to pay a sum of money to another person. Plainly, it may arise under a judgment or other court order. The obligation to pay a sum of money under an unregistrable, unrecognised foreign judgment is a “debt” within the meaning of Section 267 of the 1986 Act.
AUTHORITY IN MALAYSIA
Because Malaysia is a common law jurisdiction, the UK Supreme Court’s decision in Drelle is persuasive. The practical effects and implications of the Drelle case on Malaysian law are as follows:
|
Situation |
Effect of Drelle |
Reason |
|
Individual debtor |
Probably none |
Section 3(1)(i) of the Insolvency Act 1967 lists the non-payment of a “judgment debt” under a final judgment or final order as an act of bankruptcy. Similar to the English 1914 Act, it requires a “judgment debt” on which execution can be commenced.
This means the creditor must first register the foreign judgment under the Reciprocal Enforcement of Judgments Act 1958 (“REJA”) or sue on the judgment at common law.
|
|
Company debtor (non-REJA judgment) |
Potentially significant |
Section 466 of the Companies Act 2016 allows for a winding-up petition to be presented in court, where the company is indebted in excess of RM50,000.00. The word “indebted” is similar to the word “debt” in Section 267 of the 1986 Act. It does not require a judgment debt. A creditor can argue it may serve a demand based on the unrecognised foreign judgment as it is an “indebtedness” by the company.
|
|
Any debtor (REJA judgment) |
Unclear |
Section 7 of REJA bars any route other than registration:
“No proceedings for the recovery of a sum payable under a judgment of a superior court, being a judgment to which this Part applies, other than proceedings by way of registration of the judgment, shall be entertained by any court in Malaysia.”
Arguably, this could mean that in the case of REJA judgments, a statutory demand cannot be issued on a company until it is registered. However, this does produce an unusual result where a statutory demand can be issued on a non-REJA judgment but not a REJA judgment, when REJA was intended to facilitate easier recognition of foreign judgments from reciprocal countries.
|
CONCLUSION
Drelle confirms that at common law, a final foreign money judgment creates a debt from the moment it is given, whether or not a local court has recognised it. In Malaysia, the effect would likely depend on who the debtor is and where the judgment comes from.
If you require any advice on the enforcement of foreign judgments, please contact Mr Siva Kumar Kanagasabai (reachable at kumar@hhq.com.my) or Ms Hannah Choong (reachable at hannah@hhq.com.my).
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice or legal opinion. It should not be relied upon as a substitute for specific legal advice. No person should act (or refrain from acting) based on this article without obtaining advice on the specific facts and circumstances. Halim Hong & Quek does not accept responsibility or liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this article. Halim Hong & Quek reserves the right to update, amend or withdraw this article at any time. All rights reserved.
Subscribe to DISPUTES DECODED BY HHQ, our bi-monthly legal update, at https://mailchi.mp/hhq/2nofd6rjlt to receive our latest legal updates and articles. You may also visit the HHQ website at https://hhq.com.my/insights/ for further articles and insights from our team.
About the authors
Siva Kumar Kanagasabai
Senior Partner
Head of Dispute Resolution Practice Group
Halim Hong & Quek
kumar@hhq.com.my
○
Hannah Choong
Associate
Dispute Resolution
Halim Hong & Quek
hannah@hhq.com.my