˂  Back

Determining Whether Installation Works Constitute “Construction Work” Under CIPAA 2012

INTRODUCTION

 

The Court of Appeal in GIIB Healthcare Products Sdn Bhd v Glomaxes Latex Glove Manufacturer Sdn Bhd and another appeal [2026] MLJU 4064; [2026] CLJU 3337 held that the fabrication, installation and commissioning of a glove dipping line affixed to a factory constituted construction work within the meaning of Section 4 of the Construction Industry Payment and Adjudication Act 2012 (“CIPAA”).

 

The Court considered the purpose, nature and degree of affixation to the factory. Although the installation works took place after completion of the factory, they still fell within the definition of construction work under CIPAA.

 

BACKGROUND FACTS

 

On 25.2.2021, Glomaxes Latex Glove Manufacturer Sdn Bhd (“Glomaxes”) submitted a quotation to GIIB Gloves Manufacturing Sdn Bhd (“GGM”) for the “Turnkey Project Dual Process Double Former Online Powder Free Glove Dipping Line” (“Works”) at the factory premises (“Building”).

 

GGM issued a purchase order on 1.3.2021 appointing Glomaxes to carry out the Works for RM42,780,000.00. By mutual agreement, GGM assigned the contract to GIIB Healthcare Products Sdn Bhd (“GIIB”) on 16.7.2021.

 

Glomaxes submitted progress claims between 15.1.2022 and 25.2.2022. When GIIB failed to pay, Glomaxes commenced statutory adjudication under CIPAA.

 

On 7.11.2022, the adjudicator ordered GIIB to pay Glomaxes RM14,393,877.80, together with costs and interest.

 

On 7.10.2024, GIIB applied to set aside the adjudication decision, contending that the adjudicator had acted in excess of his jurisdiction because Glomaxes’ claim did not arise under a construction contract. Glomaxes applied to enforce the decision on 15.10.2024.

 

The High Court agreed with the adjudicator that the fabrication, installation and commissioning of the line constituted construction work.

 

On 14.1.2025, the High Court dismissed GIIB’s application and allowed Glomaxes’ application. GIIB appealed against both orders.

 

FINDINGS OF THE COURT OF APPEAL

 

The critical issue in this case was whether the Works constituted construction work as defined and intended by Section 4 of CIPAA.

 

Section 4 defines ‘construction work’ to include the installation of electrical or mechanical work and any work forming an integral part of the works described in paragraphs (a) to (e) of the definition.

 

Whether the Works Were a Fixture

 

GIIB contended that the Works were a removable chattel, akin to a drink vending machine placed in a building that had already been constructed. Glomaxes contended that the Works were a fixture affixed to the Building for the production of gloves.

 

The Court took the view that the Works had to be a fixture to constitute construction work in this case. A fixture is an article so attached to land as to form part of it in law.

 

An article resting on its own weight alone is treated as a chattel unless the party asserting that it forms part of the land shows that it was intended to do so.

 

If it is affixed, even slightly, it is treated as part of the land unless the party contending that it is a chattel shows that it was intended to remain one.

 

Nature, Degree and Purpose of Affixation

 

From the pictorial evidence, the Court found that the Works were by nature a combination of civil, mechanical and electrical works affixed to the Building. The Works did not rest on their own weight alone, as fasteners secured them to the Building.

 

The Court likened the Works to mechanical and electrical equipment normally affixed to buildings, such as air-conditioning and fire protection systems.

 

More importantly, the Court found that the purpose of the Works and the affixation was “for the enjoyment of the Building”, which was used for the production of gloves.

 

Installation After Completion of the Building

 

The Court held that the fixture comprising the construction work need not be installed concomitantly with the construction of the building.

 

Construction work may be carried out before construction of the building begins, such as piling work, or after completion of the building, such as refurbishment or renovation. The Works were therefore construction work notwithstanding that they were carried out after completion of the Building.

 

Outcome

 

The Court of Appeal affirmed that the Works constituted construction work and that the parties’ contract was a construction contract for the purposes of CIPAA. The Court of Appeal dismissed both appeals.

 

CONCLUSION AND KEY TAKEAWAYS

 

Whether the Works were a fixture turned on the nature and degree of their affixation and, more importantly, the purpose of that affixation.

 

The timing of the installation did not determine the issue. The Works constituted construction work notwithstanding that they were carried out after completion of the Building.

 

Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice or legal opinion. It should not be relied upon as a substitute for specific legal advice. No person should act (or refrain from acting) based on this article without obtaining advice on the specific facts and circumstances. Halim Hong & Quek does not accept responsibility or liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this article. Halim Hong & Quek reserves the right to update, amend or withdraw this article at any time. All rights reserved.

 

Subscribe to DISPUTES DECODED BY HHQ, our bi-monthly legal update, at https://mailchi.mp/hhq/2nofd6rjlt to receive our latest legal updates and articles. You may also visit the HHQ website at https://hhq.com.my/insights/ for further articles and insights from our team.


About the authors

Chew Jin Heng

Principal Associate
Dispute Resolution
Halim Hong & Quek
jhchew@hhq.com.my


Our Services

© 2026 Halim Hong & Quek