˂  Back

“As Is Where Is” Does Not Mean “Without Liability”

The phrase “as is where is” is commonly used in sale and purchase agreements involving land. However, does such a clause automatically absolve a vendor from liability for damage occurring after the agreement is executed? Further, does a purchaser waive its right to claim damages by proceeding with completion despite discovering the damage?

 

These issues were considered by the Court of Appeal in Golden Harvest Palms Sdn Bhd v Seri Jenjarom Plantation Sdn Bhd (In Liquidation) & Ors [2026] CLJU 3522, which concerned damage to an oil palm plantation pending completion of a land sale transaction.

 

Background Facts

 

The dispute arose from a Sale and Purchase Agreement (“SPA”) dated 30 December 2016 involving approximately 196.73 acres of agricultural land in Tawau, Sabah (“Land”). The SPA was entered into between the 1st Respondent (“Vendor”) and one Sunita Shalini Sankey, who assigned her rights and obligations under the SPA to the Appellant (“Purchaser”).

 

On 21 April 2017, the Purchaser discovered that several oil palms had been damaged and that the younger palms were not producing any yield. The balance purchase price had been deposited with solicitors for the Vendor’s liquidator by 28 April 2017.

 

The Purchaser subsequently appointed an expert to conduct a formal due diligence inspection of the Land. The report dated 22 August 2017 revealed that several blocks of mature oil palms had been poisoned with the herbicide “Gramoxone” sometime between April and July 2017, and the younger palms had failed to yield due to mismanagement. The expert assessed the total loss of revenue at RM950,000.00.

 

Despite these discoveries, the transaction was completed on 10 October 2018 following the release of the balance purchase price. After the Vendor failed to satisfy the Purchaser’s demand for RM950,000.00, the Purchaser commenced an action for breach of contract in the Sessions Court. The Vendor subsequently initiated third-party proceedings against its former directors seeking contribution or indemnity.

 

The Sessions Court dismissed the claim, and the High Court affirmed the decision. The Purchaser then appealed to the Court of Appeal.

 

Issues for Determination

 

Although the appeal also raised a procedural issue concerning the main action and third-party proceedings, the more substantive issues relating to the land sale transaction were as follows:

 

  • • Whether the Purchaser’s claim was precluded by the “as is where is” provision under Clause 1 of the SPA, or whether the Vendor’s express obligation to maintain the crops under Clause 10(e) of the SPA was applicable.
  • • Whether the Purchaser had waived its right to claim damages by making payment of the balance purchase price.

 

Findings of the Court of Appeal

 

The “As Is Where Is” Clause and the Vendor’s Obligation to Maintain the Crops

 

The Vendor relied on Clause 1 of the SPA, which provided for the sale of the Land on an “as is where is” basis. The Purchaser, however, relied on Clause 10(e), which required the Vendor to continue maintaining and keeping up the crops pending delivery of vacant possession.

 

Applying the principle generalia specialibus non derogant, as recognised in Grundt v Great Boulder Proprietary Gold Mined Ltd [1948] 1 All ER 21, the Court of Appeal held that the general “as is where is” provision could not override the specific and continuing obligation under Clause 10(e).

 

The Court also accepted that the Vendor owed an implied duty to preserve the Land pending completion. Under a contract for the sale of land, the vendor holds the property as constructive trustee for the purchaser and is under a duty to take reasonable care to ensure that the property does not deteriorate during the period between the execution of the contract and the delivery of possession.

 

The Court of Appeal ultimately found that the Vendor had breached both its express obligation under Clause 10(e) and its implied duty to preserve the property.

 

The Purchaser’s Right to Claim Damages Despite Payment of the Balance Purchase Price

 

The courts below found that the Purchaser had waived its right to claim damages by proceeding with the payment of the balance purchase price despite knowing about the contents of the due diligence report. The High Court also relied on Clause 31(b) of the SPA, holding that the Purchaser had been entitled to terminate the agreement and that its failure to exercise that right precluded it from subsequently claiming damages.

 

The Court of Appeal disagreed on three grounds, namely, the chronology of events, the express terms of the SPA and the doctrine of election.

 

Firstly, the evidence showed that the balance purchase price had been deposited by 28 April 2017, whereas the due diligence report was only prepared on 22 August 2017. It could not, therefore, be said that the Purchaser had made payment with knowledge of a report that did not yet exist.

 

Secondly, Clause 23 of the SPA contained an express non-waiver provision stipulating that knowledge or acquiescence in any breach shall not operate as a waiver. It also preserved each party’s right to insist on strict performance of the agreement notwithstanding such knowledge or acquiescence. Accordingly, the Purchaser’s knowledge of the damage to the crops and its continued performance of the SPA did not, without more, amount to a waiver of its right to claim damages.

 

Thirdly, Clause 31(b) of the SPA entitled the Purchaser to terminate the SPA if the property was damaged or destroyed before payment of the balance purchase price, provided the damage was not caused by the Purchaser, with all monies paid to be refunded without interest. However, the clause did not impose an obligation upon the Purchaser to terminate the SPA.

 

Referring to the trite principle in Chandris v Isbrandtsen-Moller Co Inc [1951] 1 KB 240, the Court of Appeal affirmed that an innocent party who elects not to treat a contract as repudiated does not thereby relinquish its right to claim for damages arising from the breach. By proceeding with the transaction, the Purchaser merely elected to affirm the SPA, which did not automatically extinguish its right to recover damages arising from the Vendor’s breach.

 

Conclusion

 

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and found the Vendor liable for breaching its express and implied duties to preserve the Land. However, as the Purchaser’s claim for RM950,000.00 represented only an estimated loss of revenue, the matter was remitted to the Sessions Court for an assessment of the exact quantum of damages.

 

Key Takeaways

 

The Court of Appeal’s decision provides two important reminders for land sale transactions.

 

First, a general “as is where is” clause should not automatically be treated as a blanket exemption from liability. The agreement must be construed as a whole, taking into account any specific obligations undertaken by the parties.

 

Second, a purchaser’s decision to proceed with completion does not, without more, amount to a waiver of a claim for damages. The relevant contractual provisions and the chronology of events must be considered.

 

Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice or legal opinion. It should not be relied upon as a substitute for specific legal advice. No person should act (or refrain from acting) based on this article without obtaining advice on the specific facts and circumstances. Halim Hong & Quek does not accept responsibility or liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this article. Halim Hong & Quek reserves the right to update, amend or withdraw this article at any time. All rights reserved.

 

Subscribe to DISPUTES DECODED BY HHQ, our bi-monthly legal update, at https://mailchi.mp/hhq/2nofd6rjlt to receive our latest legal updates and articles. You may also visit the HHQ website at https://hhq.com.my/insights/ for further articles and insights from our team.


About the authors

Meyer Thor Xiao Xin
Senior Associate
Dispute Resolution
Halim Hong & Quek
meyer.thor@hhq.com.my


Our Services

© 2026 Halim Hong & Quek